The false story is Story #2: "The Miracle Machine".
Story #1: Vincent Price's Possessed Grandmother was found in Haunted Houses for the Millions by Susy Smith.
Story #3: A Dream of Treasure was found in Strange Unsolved Mysteries, Volume 1 by Phyllis Raybin Emert.
Story #4: The Werewolf of Hexham was found in There’s Something in the Woods by Nick Redfern.
