1. News & Issues

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: What do you think is the best explanation for the star of Bethlehem?

Responses: 26

By , About.com Guide

What best explains the account of the star of Bethlehem. Was it a comet, supernova, planetary conjunction, UFO, a myth, or a genuine miracle? What's Your Theory?

ufo

I have seen that star. I was 10 years old over the sky of baghdad
—Guest fred

Great comments

I never thought much about the so-called star but it really made me think. Personally, I believe this whole idea of Jesus began with extra-terrestrial intelligience trying to help this planet. I also don't believe mankind came from this planet and we were brought here by another species. Jesus, according to his words, was far superior in thinking to men in those days. He brought us a message that is still literally ignored today. I believe those that brought him (and other prophets) here are still watching out for this planet very carefully. It's nice to read all the comments just to see how many people really think out there and not just believe what they are told.
—Guest Anita

The Star of Bethelem

It may be an UFO craft who guided the magicians then later was guarding the birth of that"starseed"named Emmanuel(God is with us)or Jesus.I'm a humanist and I believe in the UFO's.
—Guest aliencita

New understanding

The Bible says; "the kingdom of heaven is within you". It also says "there will be great signs in the heavens". The star of bethlehem is a great sign in heaven. It is a reference, in figurative language, to a persons convicting conscience increasing in influence as we move into the early years of the new millenium.
—Guest fej

Mark Twain

Mark Twain said, "Faith is believing what you know ain't so." How true that is! Perhaps someone who thinks that some magical being in the sky is guiding the Christians, and the star is one example of this, can explain why Christians cannot agree on the basics. Is the Pope the representative of God? Is the bread a symbol or really the actual body of Christ? Is birth control sinful? Where is the divine starry guidance?
—Guest Truthseeker

Problem

There is one problem to all this: The star appeared around 6 BC., the time of the census, but the gospels also refer to the attempt of King Herod to find the Christ child and kill him. Herod died ten years before the census and before the star, so obviously the Bible is wrong about the entire episode.
—Guest Truthseeker

Celestrial Possibilities

All these comments have merit. The power(s) that created this universe and life on this rock would be capable of making sure that the stars may later tell the tale. We have to remember that many wise men wrote down their opinions. They did not know for sure, and neither will we.
—Guest RONeal

Bethalem Star

I always thought the Bethlehem Star was an astronomical alignment of stars and one or two planets.
—Guest Deb

New Jerusalem

Revelations.21 [2] And I John saw the holy city, new Jerusalem, coming down from God out of heaven... [3]... Behold, the tabernacle of God is with men, and he will dwell with them, and they shall be his people, and God himself shall be with them... Shined like a light. Revelations.21 [11] Having the glory of God: and her light was like unto a stone most precious, even like a jasper stone, clear as crystal; The measurements of New Jerusalem. Revelations.21 [15] And he that talked with me had a golden reed to measure the city, and the gates thereof, and the wall thereof. [16] And the city lieth foursquare, and the length is as large as the breadth: and he measured the city with the reed, twelve thousand furlongs (1500 miles). The length and the breadth and the height of it are equal. John was supposedly taken to this New Jerusalem which would have been around the time of Jesus.
—jahu56

Satan's work

The Magi saw the star / light in the sky and went to Jerusalem. After they had been told that there was no new-born child there, they were asked to find it and return to Jerusalem and tell the king were it was. Why? So that he could go and destroy the competition. Who was interested in destroying Jesus? I guess most of you won't need the title I chose to know the answer. It's interesting to note that there's no mention of the star / light moving until they had visited Jerusalem.
—mickep

Star

Every year at the same time (Dec. 24/25) a large star called Sirius brightens the sky and three other less bright stars shine in a row behind Sirius like they were following it. The ancients of the time called those three trailing stars (actually the three stars that make up the belt of Orion) The Three Kings. It is not a unique event, it happens every year at the same time when the sun stops moving lower in the sky (days get shorter) and begins to rise back up higher into the sky (days get longer). The Sun rises and brings more light into the world. Sound familiar?
—Guest Scorccio

Star of Bethlehem

I have been doing a lot of reading of late and wonder if our interpretation of the events in the Bible are all wrong. Many scientists are looking at the events in the Bible and interpret them in a scientific way while spiritual people will interpret them in another way. The spiritual interpretation of the story might suggest that the Star of Bethlehem is God's presence and is now with Jesus. In the past, people may have lost their connection with God, and Jesus may have come to restore this connection. I have come to the conclusion, there are many ways to interpret the stories in the Bible and they are all correct. I believe we need to find the spiritual interpretation of the text in order to understand the meaning of the content. This isn't easy. We may need some help and it is best to appreciate what others have to say and learn from each other.
—Guest Thea

Embellishment story

Matthew wrote his gospel about 30 years after the supposed birth of Jesus. In order to make his story stand out from all of the other gospels, he added a couple of details, such as the star.
—kernunnos13

the star of Bethlehem?

I think that it was a UFO, being used to direct the Three Wise men to Joseph And Marie, therefore the Baby Jesus.
—Guest pepsiman1611

what i see

i have no theory cept every night i see a star from 1am to 3am and i wake up either at 2:12 am or at 3:30 am and see it EVERYnight only during those hours and it changes its location in a hour from west to north to east all the time forming like a pyramid
—Guest unknown wiseman

What's Your Theory?

What do you think is the best explanation for the star of Bethlehem?

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.